• Blog
  • YouTube
  • Book
  • About
  • Contributors
  • Shop
  • Contact
Terra Obscura - Culture | Theory | High Strangeness
  • Blog
  • YouTube
  • Book
  • About
  • Contributors
  • Shop
  • Contact
Terra Obscura - Culture | Theory | High Strangeness

The Alien Cosmic Expo, an International Panel of "Experts", and Why I'm Getting All Riled Up.

5/10/2016
Picture


On June 25th, The Alien Cosmic Expo in Brantford Ontario will play host to the first ever international panel on the existence of UFOs and Extraterrestrials using primarily Canadian government documents; suggesting that Canada, along with many other nations, have and are studying the UFO phenomenon. This massive collection of government files, according to the Research and Development team behind this panel, allegedly claims Canada is well aware of the UFO issue and that some of the evidence suggests that these UFOs rely upon intelligent operation.


Ok, I may have a few concerns here...

According to Bob Mitchell’s blog,

“[An] independent Canadian Research and Development Team has been established. Its mandate is:
- To assemble a panel of world-renowned experts in the field of UFOs to provide evidence about     the existence of the phenomenon, and;
-To assemble a second panel, one composed of journalists and academics to challenge and         question the experts on UFO evidence.”

Mitchell goes on to invite open minded skeptics to attend and attempt to counter the evidence as its presented to the expert panel. 

Again, from Mitchell’s blog, 
​

“Based on this set of circumstances it is safe to conclude questions about the existence of the UFO phenomenon remain in the dark and that a public hearing on this matter is imperative. Now that verified evidence has been compiled, there is a legitimate opportunity for journalists to become an integral part of, and a voice in the public inquiry – a voice Canadians have never heard before.”

***
As an open-minded and romantic skeptic concerning the UFO phenomenon as well as an active FI with MUFON, I do have a few initial questions for the “expert” panel.


  1. What constitutes an “expert” in the field of Ufology?

    What is Ufology and who establishes credibility in this field of study? By nature, most, if not all, Ufological data is circumstantial and speculative; how then can expertise be formed? Is it the person who has heard the most stories? Is it the person who has investigated the most reports? Is it the person who has published the most books? No field of study so loosely establishes credibility and expertise as Ufology does. Why do the men on this “expert” panel speak for the field of Ufology?


  2. Why does the press release pre-suppose the “reality” of ET and abduction?

    In a press release by ZNN,

    “Experts will present their case in support of the UFO reality, the existence of extraterrestrials and what world governments, Pentagon, White House, NORAD and Vatican officials know about this issue.”

    So this expert panel is already slanted and biased? I’ve read the work of many of the panel members. There is a clear bias. Is this a rational unbiased exploration into the potential reality or mythology of the UFO phenomenon?

  3. What is the purpose of the second panel of skeptics? 
            Is the second panel designed to provide counter evidence to the biased expert panel?                           Will this panel of “open minded skeptics” have access to the same files the experts do? Will it             be a fair debate, or, as Admiral Ackbar, a famous alien who lived a long time ago in a galaxy                 far far away once said, “It’s a trap?” 
            How many skeptics are willing to enter the lion’s den with the potential and probable reality                 that they will not be provided with all the details the experts are? One would also hope that                 this panel of experts are somewhat skeptical themselves, and hopefully rational. However,                   many of the experts on the panel have made very extraordinary claims with no evidence to                 support them. Even when they have evidence, it is pretty dubious (MJ-12, I’m talking about                   you).​

***
Ufology is a collection of stories, circumstantial evidence, and speculation, and there is nothing wrong with that. We must accept the reality of the situation. I am a young ufologist, I am open minded, but I am not deluded by government reports concerning pieces of strange metal from outer space (see Mitchell’s blog, link is posted below). Government reports are made by people. People think and believe many things. Just because there is a report does not make it true, it merely suggests that the person or persons who wrote it thought it was from outer space.
I would love to attend this discussion, but I would shy away from calling it a “debate” or “hearing” as these terms presuppose a fair and democratic argument upon equal footing. No skeptic or debunker can provide exact and perfect counter evidence to a UFO report, sighting or incident. Similarly, no proponent or believer can provide exact and perfect evidence to actually support a UFO report, sighting or incident. We have a collective mythos built upon ideologies and cultural storytelling. It is beautiful, like Shakespeare, and like his historical plays, probably just as historically accurate. 
Do people see strange things in the sky? Of course they do. Has the government logged some of these reports, explored and even studied them? Of course. To suggest, however, that these reports are solid and unquestionable evidence for extraterrestrials and abductions is, to quote Shakespeare’s Macbeth, “full of sound and fury signifying nothing…” 
The conference itself presupposes the existence of UFOs as alien spacecraft. Mud will be slung, but not at the “UFO experts”. Keep your head down and wear something you can get a little dirty…


Here is a link to Mitchell’s blog if you wish to read more about this event.

​-M.J. Banias
3 Comments
Ryan link
5/10/2016 10:14:24 am

I was really looking forward to this event, but just like you, are very skeptical at how hard the ET reality is embedded in these press releases. Shouldn't it be more of a conversation than having some very credible (and some not so much) individuals forced to take an ETH stance? Either way, I hope some good press comes from this event, and I guess we'll see how it all plays out. Will you be attending and covering it, MJ?

Reply
MJ Banias
5/10/2016 10:55:00 am

I am not sure Ryan. It would require some financial decision making on my part to make it out to Ontario.

I have nothing but the utmost respect for a couple of the panelists. They have promoted Ufology well. While I am concerned with some claims they make, we all move forward in different ways.

I'm just concerned about my bullshit meter going nova...

Reply
Sue Demeter-St Clair link
5/10/2016 10:42:41 am

UFO "expurts" and their egos as they were called back in the day over on EBK's UFO Updates have done nothing to advance our understanding of the phenomenon and only serve to push their own agendas, usually lining their own pockets $$$$ at the expense of true believers.

You are very right to question the use of the word science in any of this as it is has more in common with a religious gathering or Psychic fair.

Of course skeptics are invited as its a marketing ploy to fill seats. Any controversy is good if it means possible press.

Overall this is embarrassing. MUFON Canada has gone very much downhill since the 1990s and HQ really should distance itself from the circus IF they ever want to be viewed seriously by the mainstream public.

This type of thing hurts UFOlogy.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Archives

    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    November 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015

    Categories

    All
    Alien Abduction
    Aliens
    Astronomy
    Conspiracy
    Critical Theory
    Cryptozoology
    Culture
    Disclosure
    Ethics
    Exophilosophy
    History
    Monsters
    Movies
    Philosophy
    Planets
    Religion
    Reviews
    Science
    Science Fiction
    Solar System
    Television
    Ufology
    UFOs

    RSS Feed

© COPYRIGHT 2015. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Photos used under Creative Commons from FolsomNatural, Amanclos, Ryan Hallock, Chico Boomba, 13winds, PhotoAtelier, Bill Brussard // www.theeyeandthestreet.com, MEDIODESCOCIDO, FolsomNatural, Anthony Quintano, DragonRal, U.S. Naval Forces Central Command/U.S. Fifth Fleet, interdimensionalguardians, steevithak, Jessica_Branstetter, Biblioteca Rector Machado y Nuñez, interdimensionalguardians, IBiAFoddoAbbarad, Steve Snodgrass, Sunfox, ezhikoff, smilejustbcuz, claudiaheidelberger, Sierragoddess, DragonRal, FolsomNatural, kryshen, Metropolico.org, Kevin M. Gill, Aseptic Void, Wiertz Sébastien, izarbeltza, Jason Riedy, Macro-roni